Bonus: 1984

The novel 1984 by George Orwell has always attracted me because its setting depicts a dystopian society. I have always wondered how the future would unfold whether the human race is close to a utopian or a dystopian society. The mystery of the future taps my imagination, and I cannot help but imagine. The novel itself has a different writing style than a modern book such as What is the What or The Kite Runner, but in a sense, the writing style is refreshing. It makes the readers think a little bit harder especially when the characters in the novel uses Newspeak which is daunting and creepy.

Their Eyes Were Watching God

Feminist thinking wrapped inside a creatively succinct black literature. Such is the case of Zora Neale Hurston's Their Eyes Were Watching God. Upon reading this short novel, my mind was expanded and opened with the racism, sexism, and ageism that a person, in the novel's case, Janie, can face throughout his or her life. Before reading the actual text, I read the introduction and short essays of authors and leaders who were influenced by the novel, and their opinions stuck with me, troubling me throughout reading the novel if I was justified or objective with the subjects. Yet mid-way through the book, I let go of the my insecurities and read the book like a typical reader, still picking up the same lessons that I did during the beginning half of the novel. The book left me, as a woman, as a teenager, and as a non-white, empowered that regardless of the oppositions that I may face in the future, I can prevail just as Janie did in the novel.

What is the What

What is the What in and of itself is a great "fictional" novel, but absolutely amazing as an autobiography. One can really pick up literary usages, but also lessons that one can apply on life within the novel's passages. It's hard to determine which is actual and which is fictional, and it goes to show how the passages mesh together and flow very fluidly. The authors, Dave Eggers and Valentino Achak Deng have done a wonderful job in making a 500-page book widely entertaining and equally as lovable. The authors' message came through the pages of the novel. I have a new-found love for the Sudanese people- their memories are my memories, and their challenges my challenges.
I did not only acquire literary symbols appropriate to better my AP Literature understanding, but also a greater appreciation for life itself- its innocence, its futility, and especially its fragility.

The Kite Runner

The Kite Runner ranks as one of my most favorite books. The writing feels real, as if it is an autobiography rather than a novel. I guess, after reading What is the What I figured that such adventures and happenings occurred in the world. Naturally, I did not understand nor even tried to understand the circumstances of the Middle East. I always assumed that Afghanistan and other Middle Eastern countries are always at war, yet the writing of The Kite Runner completely changed my attitude towards people. I realized that people live normally and in their own cultural standards- feeling the same things that people all around the world feel and doing the same things that people all around the world do.
The novel, to me, is not just a weighty, AP literature-type novel, but also an eye-opener with the Afghan culture. Before I read the novel, I didn't even know that I had some form of Afghan racism, but I just knew that some unknown questions that I had towards the culture has all been answered.

The Kite Runner- Relationships and Selling Soul to the Devil

Khaled Hosseini perfectly captures the trauma of an unhealthy father and son relationship, and the deep friendship between separate castes that exists between his characters in The Kite Runner.

Amir's first word was Baba, or father, while Hassan's first word was Amir. Hosseini foreshadows the tangled relationship of the characters in his novel. Baba is the epitome of greatness, building orphanages, giving to the poor, and helping any or all those who are in need, yet Amir wonders about Baba's love towards him as he himself does not advocate Baba's characteristics. As a child deprived of parental love, Amir yearns to be accepted, yet finds that the unconditional love that he deserves from Baba is being given to Hassan, the Hazara servant that Baba has no connection to (or so Amir thinks.) Although Amir is the socially legitimate child of Baba and is therefore showered with materialism, Amir envies the servant boy in whom Baba devotes himself to. Hassan, on the other hand, serves Amir and always ensues his loyalty towards Amir. Both Hassan and Amir value the brotherhood they share, yet Hassan more so. It seems this way since Amir is constantly haunted by his envy towards Hassan for fatherly love while Hassan is dearly beloved by his own father Ali and Amir's Baba. And so Amir is separated by his needs and his loves, so metaphorically, he sold his soul to the devil.

The devil in this case is the sociopath, Assef, although not completely. In the winter of the kite-fighting festival, Amir is nagged by his overwhelming need to make his father proud and to be finally treated with love and affection. He envisions coming home with the last fallen kite and being warmly greeted by his father, and so sends Hassan to run for the kite. However, Hassan finds trouble with Assef and is then violated all for the happiness of Amir. Amir witnesses everything, yet chooses not to act according to a hero's action. At the moment he ran away, Amir sold his soul, being Hassan and friendship and love and innocence, to the devil, Assef and his demonic behavior, in return for the love and devotion of his father which only lasts for a while. If Amir chooses to stand up against Assef to save Hassan, he would have gotten the kite and the respect of his father, but like a typical person, Amir fears an encounter with the devil.

Throughout his life, Amir is haunted by his curse, signifying that the devil still holds his soul, and has a chance for redemption when Rahim Khan asks a 38 year old Amir to return to Kabul, Afghanistan to retrieve Sohrab, the spitting image of Hassan. Amir then has a face to face encounter with the devil, Assef, ironically dressed as a Taliban leader, a supposed man of God. One can think of an encounter with the devil as a similar story of an encounter with Hades, the Greek god of the underworld, in parts as Hercules or as Persephone. After a horrible encounter involving broken ribs, jaws, various body parts, and a split mouth like Hassan's cleft lip, Amir redeems himself from an encounter with the devil, gets his soul back, and saves a metaphorical Hassan (the clever author chose to make Sohrab look exactly like the boy Hassan) from the trauma that Amir could not do when he was a mere child.

The Kite Runner- Winter

"Now is the winter of our discontent
Made glorious summer by this son of York;
And all the clouds that lour'd upon our house
In the deep bosom of the ocean buried."

-Shakespeare's Richard III I.I.1-4

Winter. The season of snow, chills, and hot chocolate. Yet in Khaled Hosseini's The Kite Runner, winter signifies the end, whether they be of a smile, of friendship, or of innocence. Winter has always been associated with old age or even death. In The Kite Runner, winter is ironically the season that families and children get together to witness the kite tournament, an Afghan game involving kites battling until the last one is left standing. Even if the glass strings cut the hands of individual players, the excitement of the game in the middle of winter vacation becomes the talk of the remainder of the school year. The protagonist, Amir, envisions himself that this year he will be the winner, and in truth, he did, but metaphorically, he also lost. The end of the chapter five even states an ominous note that "that was the winter that Hassan stopped smiling."

After Amir's win of the kite-fighting tournament, Hassan serves to make him happy by running after the losing blue kite. However, Hassan encounters trouble with Assef, a sociopath, and his gang of ne'er-do-well's. Amir searches for Hassan, and witnesses the horrendous vision of Hassan's raping in a grimy alley. Amir is placed with two choices- to stop Assef or to run away, and being only a child, Amir escapes the sight. Everything changes since that point forward. Amir loses his innocence and like Richard III's speech, the guilt is "in the deep bosom of the ocean buried," and consumes the remainder of his life, affecting his choices and perception of himself. The spring and summer of Amir's childhood days are over, only replaced by the uninhibited loss of innocence, and overwhelming guilt which pervades all aspects of Amir's life. Hassan no longer smiles because Amir does not let him or rather because Amir does not nor cannot forgive himself. Their deep friendship is shattered by the image of Hassan being corrupted, an image so obscure and unthinkable that the only way to end the guilt is to shut down the normalcy of childhood infinitely.

Dave Eggers and Valentino Achak Deng

Dave Eggers
and
Valentino Achak Deng

The authors of What is the What and the co-founders of the Valentino Achak Deng Foundation which aids the Sudanese people of Deng's hometown of Marial Bai.

What is the What- Miss Gladys and the Women of Achak's Life

The latter parts of What is the What becomes more of a bildungsroman, a coming-of-age story which reflects on the road from youth to adulthood, and this thematic element is witnessed through the characters Miss Gladys, Maria, and Tabitha. The characters' overt behaviors as independent women, being questionable in the Sudanese culture, also challenge the the preconceptions about the roles of men and women.

Miss Gladys, a woman who works as a drama teacher in Kakuma, captures the eyes and taps the senses and emotional states of all boys and girls in the refuge town. Her behavior as an independent woman who seems in charge of her own sexuality and mentality electrifies the people around her, especially Achak. Achak, now entering manhood, is attracted to her independence and alters his ideas on women. Although Achak himself is not at all rebellious, often undergoing leadership, type-A positions, he no longer associates himself as a typical Sudanese after his encounter with the civil war and the African diaspora earlier on in life. The cultural uprooting of Sudan as well as being displaced in both Ethiopia and Kenya also aids in his indifference towards the cultural ideas on the behaviors of men and women. Before the coming of Miss Gladys, Achak's behavior towards a female friend Maria is strictly friendship. He doesn't fail to notice Maria's independent and feisty nature, but fails in witnessing her father's mistreatment of her. Maria's father only longs for Maria to be married off at the highest bride price and thereby chooses to stifle her into doing meager house chores and "womanly" duties to achieve his goal. However, once Miss Gladys enters Kakuma and Achak's life, she changes the thinking of Achak, though inadvertently. Miss Gladys creates a drama team which involves Achak and Maria, and through this, Achak notices Maria's finesse for the dramatic arts. Yet even with his realization of the stifling conditions on the roles of men and women in the Sudanese culture, Achak does not do anything about Maria's condition mainly because he does not understand his capabilities fully and has no fervent grasp on his own role in the community. But the seed of wisdom is planted.

Miss Gladys does not only attract men, she also attracts women in a different sense- women who, like Tabitha, is as strong-willed and independent as she is. Because Achak is enlightened by the grace and strength of Miss Gladys but knows he has no chance towards her, he becomes pulled by the energy and attitude of a similar person, Tabitha. If Achak begins to enter manhood while figuring out Maria's status, he finishes the mystery with Tabitha. In a way, Tabitha is the last checkpoint for Achak with his questions about coming of age. Through her, he searches within himself. The trip to Nairobi with the rest of the drama team does not only signify their accomplishments in the dramatic arts, but also serves as a quest to be alone with Tabitha for a few hours. Yet unknowingly, Achak does not recognize his true quest: to open his mind in terms of his own sexuality, and the aches of his life at Kakuma. The road to Nairobi is far from treacherous, but like Circe's allure towards Odysseus and his men, Nairobi seems far from harm. The drama team wishes to not go back to Kakuma, yet in their hearts going back is right. Tabitha, in this trip, serves as Circe in that she plants the idea of running away with Achak and staying at Nairobi and seals the idea to Achak with the couple's first (and very long) kiss. Achak, wonders whether to be selfish and stay, a symbol of childishness, or to be dutiful and leave, a symbol of maturity and therefore manhood. In the end, Achak chooses not to do Circe's pleas, thereby emerging as a man as the drama team drives back to Kakuma.

The What

I ask my brother one morning: Brother, what is the What?
the what?
the What.
God knows I have the cow.
Why do I need the What?
Only He knows why.
I leave.

I ask my sister one afternoon: Sister, what is the What?
the what?
the What.
why not
...the How?
...the Why?
...the When?
...the Who?
Surely more inquisitive than asking what is the What.
I leave.

I ask my father one evening: Father, what is the What?
the what?
The What.
Go ask your mother.
I leave.

I ask my mother after a dream: Mother, what is the What?
She didn't answer.
:Mother, what is the What?
Nothing.
:Mother, what is the What?!

I turn her around.
lifeless. cold.
and then I knew.

the What.
A thing. Unknown. Unseen.
Unforgiving.
the What.

What is the What- Rebirth

Crossing a river, like a baptism, is a sense of rebirth and the beginning of a new life. With birth comes the naming of the newborn of which Achak has many, all of which differ depending on his location- Valentino, Achak, Dominic, and Gone Far to name a few. The rivers and other bodies of water that are strewn around the geography of Africa which Valentino Achak Deng encounters in the novel represent the different changes in his life, his rebirth.

1. Baptism as a child in Marial Bai-
-Official Christian Name: Valentino Deng, but most often called Achak by the people of Marial Bai.
During this time, Achak lived in innocence as the young child of a businessman. Life was simple with school, family, and friends, and the village society moved in harmony. Achak enjoyed dreaming and imagining with his friends William K. and Moses as well as the attention of his boyhood crush, Amath. The Dinkas were no different than the Arab traders Achak's father welcomed, but there were still social issues concerning different races lingering in Sudan. Eventually, the SPLA caused trouble for Marial Bai, and the government of Khartoum vanquished all inhabitants of the village forcing Achak to travel with Dut among the Lost Boys.

2. The River Gilo to Ethiopia- Death opened the eyes of a tainted Achak, yet with his young soul, Achak still hoped for a land overflowing with wealth at Ethiopia. His name at Pinyudo is Gone Far, because he is one of the few that traveled coming from the other side of Southern Sudan and survived to Ethiopia. To get to the Dinka's land of promise and freedom, the Lost Boys must cross the raging, crocodile-infested River Gilo unharmed. At Pinyudo, a camp was set up and looked over by the SPLA and the UN for the refugees of the Sudan War. However, Ethiopia was infested with hatred similar to the race/civil war happening at Sudan. The Ethiopians longed for the Dinkas to leave their land, and after a year, they attained it by attacking the refugee camp and driving the refugees out of Ethiopia.

3. The River Gilo back to Sudan (and eventually Kakuma)-
-Name: Valentino, but Achak to some friends from Marial Bai, and Gone Far from Pinyudo.
Crossing the River Gilo and witnessing the malice and murders of his fellow Dinkas, Achak's eyes are further opened to the hatred of the world. He survived crossing the rushing Gilo river while being attacked by Ethiopians. He survived the rebirthing process. He no longer retains the naive hope of a brand new life with education and wealth at his next refugee camp, but becomes morose about how his overall life has been altered indefinitely. At Kakuma, Achak rebuilds a life, even feigning a pseudo family with people from Marial Bai and Achor Achor. He holds no fondness for fighting still, but has lost all sense of his old self- his innocent self- starting with forgetting his family's face. The transformation is almost complete.

4. The Atlantic Ocean to the United States-
-Name(s): Dominic Arou, Valentino, Achak, Gone Far
After living ten years in Kakuma, a refugee camp, the Lost Boys attain a chance to emigrate out of Kakuma and foster lives in other countries. Achak, sent to Atlanta, gets ready to move again, to flee and create a better life in America. Although he no longer holds hope for the country of Sudan, he is a man now, knowing better but still holding on to hope that the gleaming country of the United States of America will provide better opportunities for the refugees. No longer does Achak swim across a body of water, he flies over it, a symbol of hope, dream, and freedom. In aspects, he is not baptized (for he is not immersed in the Atlantic Ocean) because he retains his Sudanese/Kenyan/Ethiopian identity with him. He does not look to shed his life, but to better it with opportunities and accomplishments.

What is the What- Christ Figures

In the book How to Read Literature Like a Professor, a chapter unfolds concerning the importance of Biblical characters and Christ figures. The novel What is the What has tremendous amounts of allusions to the bible regardless of the book being an autobiography. The most riveting are the allusions to Christ.

1. Monynhial-Monynhial is a little boy, a lost boy by the world's terms, that accompanied Achak and thousands of Sudanese on the road to Ethiopia. After witnessing the bombing and death of five boys while journeying, "Monynhial's eyes were without light." The lost boys continue to walk, no longer feeling remorse or even shaken by death; they become used to it, all except for Monynhial. He stops at the next village, finds a crevice inside a crater, blocks the crater with flat wood, and lives within it for three days until "deciding to die." This is similar to the life of Jesus Christ in which Monynhial also suffers being tormented and persecuted by people who retain no remorse, but only hatred for those below them. Monynhial is hunted because the government wishes to extinguish the Sudanese, and Christ is hunted because the government wishes to extinguish the King of Kings. Both witness tremendous amounts of violence and hatred toward their fellow men, but still retain a sense of innocence. It is why Monynhial could not bear the deaths of five boys while others can; he still has innocence, but alas, he could not move forward. Similarly, Christ and Monynhial's death retains an odd connection. After Christ's crucifixion, He was laid down in a garden tomb covered by a boulder, and in three days, was risen up. Monynhial also died while he is alive that is. The significance of him no longer retaining the "light in his eyes" means his spiritual death. He also laid down in a crevice-like tomb with a cover and in three days he died. Although one cannot think that a death is similar to a rising from the dead, in Monynhial's case it could be. He is free in his state of death, risen and exalted. He is not chained down by spiritual death, but is risen to heaven.

2. Open-armed Woman- When the Lost Boys are being hunted, a woman with open arms chanting, "My children. Come to your mother," entices the boys to turn around and run towards her in order to achieve asylum. However, when the boys get near, the woman lifts up a malicious gun and exterminates her "children." Although the open-armed woman is a far stretch from Christ, a few symbols are shared by the two. The woman "poses as [the children's] savior" while Christ is the savior of humanity, the children of God. Both encourage disciples with outstretched arms to come follow them. However, the woman betrays the trust of the Lost Boys, and ironically, instead of being a savior, she imposes as the annihilator.

What is The What- Quotations

1. Actual Quotation Marks i.e. "Stay here, Africa" : The author uses actual quotations in the novel when Achak is not recollecting his African memories. It seems as though Eggers utilizes quotations to distinguish between life in America as a Sudanese immigrant, while also representing Achak's adult lifestyle and mentality. I suppose when one is a child, then they are more apt to forgetting the right ways for grammar and punctuation, and Eggers shows the distinction from child and adult through the different usage of quotations and dashes. Furthermore, the quotation marks indicate actual conversation, and not merely some fictionalized conversation to move the story along.

2.Dashes i.e. --I don't care. Someday I might ride it faster. Not yet, though. : The dashes constitutes all of Achak's conversations back when he was a young refugee in Sudan. The dashes, which written on a page creates a flowy appearance, pushes Achak's recollection into that, a mere recollection. The language of the dashed conversation seems quick and intense, with a feeling of rush, and often the dashes conversation are grouped together like so:
"-Burned? By who? the boy asked. He was skeptical
-The Baggara, Deng answered.
-The Baggara? Why didn't you fight them?..." -p. 126
while the quotation marked conversations are more one liners before a lengthy explanation. The preface of the novel states that Valentino Achak Deng could not "recount some conversations that took place seventeen years ago." thereby constituting the dashes as a means for a shadowy and imagined conversation to help the story along.

What is The What- Robbers

The novel/autobiography by Dave Eggers and Valentino Achak Deng, What is the What begins with the robbery of a Sudanese immigrant Achak by, ironically, a couple of African-Americans named Tonya and Powder. Although a robbery itself is not a laughing matter, something struck me as humorous with the characters themselves. Irony is just funny to me. I can't help but notice Tonya's proclamation of "helping a sister" is achieved through theft, let alone theft from an African African, their brother and supposed comrade. They attack Achak Deng with slurs such as "African" (and other derogatory swear words) when they themselves are some part of African. Tonya and Powder steals from someone who has less materially but more internally, which leads one to think who really has the power? Who really has the one up in the situation? Why did they need to tie Achak down when he proposes no power struggle?

Their Eyes Were Watching God- Symbolisms: Water

3. Water/Baptism- In How to Read Literature Like a Professor, it states that a character's contact with water conveys a variety of issues, the overarching element of which is a cleansing. In Hurston's novel, a hurricane approaches and uproots the farming town that Janie and Tea Cake work in. Both hurry to get away from the hurricane by running, swimming, and basically using infinite strength to beat the forces of Mother Nature. On one occasion, Janie bobs up and down the mighty gushes of water, almost drowns, but manages to survive by holding on to the tail of a cow. However, a rabid dog attempts to attack her, but Tea Cake fronts the attack and getting bitten in the process.
The couple's "misadventures" with water brings to mind different issues. Both emerges from the water signifying a baptism, however, the dirty, destructive water does not seem to back up the baptism theory. However, baptism signifies change, which is what occurred during the latter parts of the book where the novel takes a dark and unfortunate turn: with the couple's changed lives, Tea Cake's madness, and his eventual death. So maybe baptism is not necessarily a change for the better? Or was Hurston playing around with the supposed idea for water, but baffles it with irony?

Their Eyes Were Watching God- Symbolisms: Christ Figure

2. Christ Figure- When Joe Starks emerges majestically from the far end of the road only looking straight ahead, Janie "ran to the pump and jerk[s] the handle" so the stranger could drink a cool glass of water. Later as the two speak, Joe Starks tell Janie his goal, his mission, to be a big voice among the blacks since he had no voice among the whites who ran things in "Georgy," and it took him nearly thirty years to fulfill his goal. He looks for a companion to join his quest.
Joe Starks action is reminiscent of Christ. The story of Starks asking Janie for water while he travels is similar to the story about Christ and the "Living Water" in the New Testament. Similarly, Starks is almost 30 to achieve and is recruiting Janie as a companion much like Christ and his disciples. Christ and Starks have the same mission and that is to be a big voice among the oppressed since both emerged from humble backgrounds- Starks being black and Christ being a Nazarene Jew.
Ironically, throughout the course of the novel Starks becomes less and less like a Christ figure when he is selected as the mayor dominates the whole town as well as belittling Janie.

Their Eyes Were Watching God- Symbolisms 1: Eating Together

1. Eating together- From the book How to Read Literature like a Professor, it says that in a novel, the process of eating together serves as a communion between beings. It can signify alliances, hostility, and acceptance. Eating is a private act, and letting someone partake of the same food that one eats means a bond is being created. In Hurston's novel, Janie when first meeting Joe Starks as a traveler, lets him in her home while they drink water and share information about each other. This act of communion takes both into another level which eventually leads to Janie leaving her first husband to join and marry Joe Starks. Later on in the novel, Tea Cake and Janie get closer as symbolized by their willingness to eat together, laugh together, and entertain each other on Janie's porch. Similar to Janie and Joe's event, Janie and Tea Cake are married as well. The act of eating together is so crucial to the novel (and in Janie's love life for that matter) because it creates alliances and bonding.

Their Eyes Were Watching God- Passage 2 Musings

"Sometimes God gits familiar with us womenfoks too and talks His inside business. He told me how surprised He was 'bout y'all turning out so smart after Him makin' yuh different; and how surprised y'all is goin' tuh be if you every find out you don't know half as much 'bout us as you think you do. It's so easy to make yo'self out God Almighty when you ain't got nothing tuh strain against but women and chickens." -Janie, p. 75

Hurston's usage of such a beautiful and ethnically-inspired language allows the novel to become more real. The language lends a feeling and air of being in the Southern area of the United States living with culturally gifted African-Americans. The language aids in appeal, but also sets the novel apart from "white" novels and gives a bigger voice, in their own voice, pertaining to African-Americans of that time.
The passage expands my thinking as well, and in a few ways, makes me proud. It heightens my sense of self and provides me with a reason to be more confident especially around men, the elder, and those who have superiority-complexes. Knowing that Hurston also was one of the down-trodden and oppressed, I am even more in awe of the wisdom that she presented in this passage.

The Buzzards

The death of the mule brings the whole town to gather around its remains to hold a faux funeral. The people of Starks' town "made great ceremony over the mule" and "mocked everything human in death" waiting for Mayor Starks' to proceed the ceremony. With a "great eulogy on [their] departed citizen," Mayor Starks flaunts his oratorial and leadership skills throughout the continuation of the gathering up until the town leaves the carcass, unburied, for the waiting buzzards. Impatient, the buzzards are holding a "flying-meet" over the ceremony, waiting for the attendance of their leader, the Parson.
Coincidentally, or rather purposefully, Hurston, the author, parallels the human-held funeral ceremony with that of the buzzards' eating ceremony. Just as the people anticipates Mayor Starks to push forward the ceremony before they can mock and imitate the remainder of the ceremony, the buzzards also anticipates the Parson to begin the rite of feasting upon the mule's carcass. One can only wonder what Hurston intended as the significance of the parallelism, and with further reading, I have created a conjecture. Since the mule represents Janie, therefore its death represents her emotional death as is later revealed with her silence and numbness in chapter 7. The Parson being an extended metaphor for Jody Starks initiates the okay for the whole town (the buzzards) to further destroy Janie, though in his and the others' minds they are honoring her, when she is already dead.

Their Eyes Were Watching God 2

Reading this novel brings an empowerment to me. I began this book with no expectations in mind, and I left this book with powerful ideas in my head. I couldn't stop thinking about Tea Cake and Janie's growth. I couldn't stop imagining the graphic life that Janie goes through, and in a way, the novel humbles me and speaks to me in a language that one barely comes across.
Janie took years to find her purpose. It took her years to rise from the deepest part of the social ladder and accept herself in a way that nothing else can touch her pride and her sense of self.

The Mule

Chapter 6 of Their Eyes Were Watching God starts with another day in Janie Starks' life as the mayor's wife. It opens with the "thought pictures" of the neighbors as they gather around the store's porch and discuss "crayon enlargements of life." Oddly enough, for half the chapter, the author focuses her writing about a mule. At first, I wondered what the mule represented; A=B is the magic equation.
So I continued reading, and as I read, the neighbors don't seem to talk about the mule anymore, but rather Janie. Janie is the mule- overworked, unappreciated, gossiped about, and stifled. Throughout the chapter Janie sympathizes with the mule. She feels its pain because it is also her pain. Although she doesn't recognize her own pain, or rather, she becomes so numb with her forced silence, she sees the mule's and yearns for its pain to stop much like she wishes her own to end. Knowingly, Janie wants the mule to not suffer anymore and through her sympathy, she begins to recognize her discontent and finally turns her life around.
Also, the mule is an extension of Janie. The mule's life draws the path for Janie's life. Much like the mule, the beginning of Janie's life is nothing but hardship masked by a false glory, but towards the end, the mule basks in happiness roaming free and unowned as Janie also basks in peace roaming free and unowned with Tea Cake.

Their Eyes Were Watching God- Passage 1 Musings

"Mouf kissin' is on uh equal and dat's natural but when dey got to bow down tuh love, dey soon straightens up." -p. 23

Throughout Janie’s life, the protagonist of Zora Neal Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God, a yearning to grasp her purpose of living and sense of self is evident. Approaching her grandmother Nanny after a misconception about love and marriage, Janie tells her grandmother about the emptiness within her household though violence and overall sadness does not ensue. Nanny then tells Janie her opinion; a quote which is important throughout the book not only as the reflection of the theme, but also the set-up for the tone.
Hurston utilizes Janie's life as a metaphor for the hardships of women, but not just any women, but black women- the lowest of the low. Janie is the symbol for the black woman with her strength to not settle for less regardless of the choices that are put before her by other people. Janie uses love as a source of freedom, viewing equality as the utmost prize. The quote speaks of Janie's search for self, but also foreshadows her marriages. With her marriages:Logan Killicks, Joe Starks, and Tea Cake, the way Hurston uses literal meaning (Killicks and Starks treating Janie like a princess, but treating her badly later on) connects to the quote. Incidentally, or rather purposefully, Tea Cake is the only one that literally kisses Janie in the novel thus giving meaning that Janie will be treated equally in their marriage. Tea Cake provides Janie with the one thing she needs most: the option to let herself free.